Apple eliminates apps in China

Apple kicked tens of thousands of products off the Chinese version of its App Store on the final day of the year to meet Beijing's demands.



The bulk of them were unlicensed games.


But civil rights campaigners have said the company needs to be more transparent about why some other apps have been removed ahead of a 31 December deadline.


The US tech firm has previously said that it is subject to local rules but sometimes challenges takedown orders.


Games licences

Apple removed about 46,000 apps from its store on New Year's Eve, according to analysis by research firm Qimai, of which 85% were games.


It said they included Ubisoft's Assassin's Creed Identity and the basketball simulation NBA 2K20, among more obscure titles.


China introduced a law four years ago saying that games must have been granted an official licence number in order to be sold in the country.


Foreign companies were banned from selling games directly to consumers, and had to partner with local firms to do so.

image captionThe deleted apps include some well-known Western games franchises

Even then, they can be hard to come by.


China's National Press and Publication Administration's website indicates it has only granted 97 video game import licences this year, some of which were for games consoles rather than apps.


Apple had originally indicated it would enforce a 31 July deadline, but later extended this to 31 December.


The App In China consultancy said that publishers had previously exploited a loophole whereby the iPhone-maker requested a developer's licence number but did not verify it, meaning any number could be submitted to its system.


Sensor Tower said Apple had already removed at least 94,000 apps from its China store this year prior to Christmas.


Google is not affected as Android devices sold within the country do not use its Play Store, and local marketplaces have already taken their own steps to be compliant.

'Inconsistent reports'


Beyond games, Chinese censors have also been waging a campaign against apps used for fraud, pornography, prostitution, gambling and violence, in addition to those that contain politically sensitive information or other content deemed to be illegal.


A crackdown earlier this month led to a ban of the American travel app TripAdvisor among dozens of others.


Apple regularly publishes a tally of the number of apps it has been ordered to remove in the country, but does not name the products involved.


One Washington-based group has said the firm needs to be more open about its actions.

"The number of apps that Apple says it removes from China each year doesn't line up with the much longer list of apps that are missing in China but commonly found in other markets," said Michelle Kuppersmith from the Campaign for Accountability last week.


"This inconsistency shows that a large number of politically sensitive apps are being pulled back from the China App Store.


"If Apple is choosing to soften its opposition to censorship in order to compete in the Chinese market, it should be transparent about that decision."


The company last commented on the matter on 21 December.


"Apple studies these requests carefully whenever we receive them, and we contest and disagree with them often," it was quoted as saying by the Wall Street Journal.


"Though the final decisions sometimes run contrary to our wishes, we believe that our customers are best served when we remain in the country providing them access to products that promote self-expression with world-class privacy protections."